GOXI

sharing in governance of extractive industries

Oil Compensation In Hoima (Uganda) Exposes Deep Seated Abuse Of Women Land Rights

The undertaking of oil exploration typically has profound social, cultural and political impacts – both negative and positive, both in the country at large and in the region of operation. Oil exploration can have a positive effect on development by creating jobs, catalyzing business and providing vital infrastructure such as roads, electricity, building schools and even better health facilities like the Buliisa Health Centre IV.

 

However, if unchecked, the negative effects can supersede the positive. Moreover, women and children in these areas are at a disproportionately at a higher risk of these consequences.

 

Around the world, inequalities often take on a gender dimension and have a greater impact on women and girls than men and boys.

 

Whereas there has been progress in the compensation processes and media has begun to report on the positives impacts of compensation monies, the disheartening impacts and effects of compensation monies on women afforded little attention. The fact of the matter is, according to testimonials, compensation monies are inflicting more pain than gain for most women in Hoima.

For instance, since compensation commenced, most of the testimonials gathered thus far detail heads of households using the money to buy cars or boda bodas, to start maize mill shops and build semi-permanent houses. Sadly, cases of women benefitting and developing are not existent or if they are, they are not properly captured.

Whilst men predominantly benefit, women are disproportionately being negatively affected. Unfortunately, there are no mechanisms or structures that address or provide remedy for these traumatizing issues and abuses that women are subjected to.

Grace Bigabwenkya, a police officer in charge of the Child and Family Unit in Hoima Poli... acknowledges that she has received several reports of family neglect and domestic violence cases ergo of compensation monies.

“Police intervened after receiving complaints from two women who alleged that their husbands abandoned them and their children after they received compensation” she narrates through her police statements.

In an interview with Oil in Uganda, Evelyn Mwambe, 37, mother of two and a resident of Kyapaloni, Buseruka village reveal that her husband vanished into thin air after receiving compensation monies without his consent.

 “My husband secretly signed for compensation without my consent,” Mwambe, who has since relocated to her parents’ home in the neighbouring Nyamasoga village, she is reportedly noted in a police statement.

In Nyamasonga Village, Rogelin Pachudaga, had been married for five years but now shares the same predicament. As for Pachudaga, her husband neglected her and took on another wife in Masindi; 50 kilometres away from Hoima town.

These incidences are revealing indeed.  From these testimonials, it seems there are limited open spaces for women to practise and enjoy their rights and the weaker institutions and structures available do not effectively reach out to the rural women to engage them in decision making processes.

 

Same cast different scripts?

Alewanita Akello, a resident of Bukona A and mother of seven says that she fears her husband will waste the compensation monies on alcohol once they are compensated. She further says that she cannot guide her husband on how to spend the money for fear of being sent back to her home.

These cases present a fraction of the challenges that women continue to experience in relation to access and control of natural resources such as land and compensation monies.  Nonetheless, it is evident that the powers of culture and traditions are still a big hindrance to women’s access to and ownership of land.

In 2012, the government, through consultant, Strategic Friends International (SFI), implemented the land-acquisition programme for the proposed oil refinery by acquiring a 29 sq. kilometre piece of land in Kabaale, Buseruka sub-county, Hoima district. Government set aside about 70 billion shillings ($27 million) for the compensation and resettlement component of this project.

Reportedly, the National Budget Framework Paper for the next financial year 2015/16, reveals that out of 2,615 property owners who opted for cash compensation, a total of 1,945, 85 per cent of the community have so far been paid as of December 2014. The framework paper also notes that the remaining 670 project-affected persons are scheduled for payment in the next financial year; three years after the project began.

The government is still undertaking a master plan to construct two-bed roomed houses in Kyakaboga parish, Buseruka sub-county in Hoima district for each of the 93 households who opted to be relocated. 

However, it is apparent that the Resettlement Action Plan did not foresee the impacts and negative effects that the compensation pay-outs would have on women. While undertaking the compensation process, the implementing agency- did not observe the constituted laws on equal rights and ownership which would have facilitated more women participation in the process.

According to a report by International Alert, women were not part of the compensation processes and those who were not offered the opportunity to co-sign the forms.  

A lack of knowledge and skills related to rights has also played a major role here; leaving many women sidelined during decision making process.

“They do not give consent or sign documents, and the compensation is mostly paid to men.  Furthermore, the documents do not have provisions for spousal consent and participation. Bank accounts opened for the compensation process are largely registered in names of men,” Godfrey Nyakahuma, Hoima Resident District Commissioner is quoted by media.

Women are the linchpins of most families and when in control of financial resources, they are more likely to devote resources to developmental activities like food, education and health unlike men who are more likely to spend it on prostitution and alcohol. It is therefore vital that the existing laws are enforced to ensure that women attain support to secure their children’s future.

While the privatization of land titles strengthens individual rights, in most cases women are often left out due to illiteracy, lack of knowledge of their rights and the lack of stringent regulatory frameworks.

According to Wilson Kiiza, an independent researcher on Bagungu culture and history, the Bugungu culture does not allow women to own land and not even the oil discovery will change the norm.

“Women did not own land in the past, Bagungu believed that, a woman will get her land at her husband's home. However, when they divorce, she had no power of ownership over her farming land,” he notes.

 Bagungu land was owned customarily and women had access to land only to collect firewood and cut grass used for thatching.

Even though the 1995 Constitution, National Land Policy and the Land Act 1998 provide for equal rights in as far as ownership of land is concerned, traditionalists argue the customary form of land tenure does not permit women to own or inherit land.  This argument may provide one explanation for the misuse of compensation monies thus widening the poverty gap.

Interestingly, it seems that customary practices may continue to override statutory law in recognition and enforcement of women’s land rights, abating unnoticed land grabbing at the family level.

It is however important to note that as  Uganda plans to commence oil production, the oil sector infrastructural developments will have even more negative impacts on women that should not be over-looked.

To move ahead strategically and sustainably, women must be granted the opportunity to access information, participate in decision making and become more actively involved in the policy and legal formulations and reviews. There should be an institution that protects women and addresses the hopes, fears, expectations, outcomes and abuses related to women and compensation.

 

Most importantly, while men are fully integrated into land issues at various levels, specific programs should be introduced to sensitize both men and women on their respective rights. On the longevity perspective, this will reduce the gender inequality over time.

Views: 425

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of GOXI to add comments!

Join GOXI

Comment by Robert on June 9, 2015 at 14:11

The key issue has as far as the entire compensation is concerned, has been failure to put the compensation money to good and secure use. Much of it has been spent on buying luxurious cars, buildings and on expensive lodges, motorbikes around Kampala. The huge blame may be placed onto government which did not consider exhaustive sensitisation workshops to help these residents put it to good use!

Conveners

           GOXI Partners

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2020   Created by Kobina Aidoo.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service